Tesla's $14 Billion Rally Eclipses Other Auto Stocks' Declines

As shares of Elon Musk’s Tesla Inc. surged, the company's market value increase far outpaced the declines suffered by its U.S.-based competitors following President Donald Trump’s latest tariff announcement.

‍

Tesla’s stock movements tend to have an outsized impact on the market due to the company’s immense valuation compared to other automakers. On Thursday, Tesla’s 1.7% gain boosted its market capitalization by approximately $14.3 billion. In contrast, while shares of General Motors Co. and Ford Motor Co. experienced steeper declines, their combined market value fell by only about $4.6 billion.

‍

“Tesla’s premium valuation is masking the broader challenges that the auto sector is facing due to tariffs,” said Dave Mazza, CEO of Roundhill Financial Inc. “Despite selling fewer vehicles than Honda or Nissan last year, Tesla’s stock rose today even as the rest of the auto industry struggles with trade-related concerns.”

‍

Although many automakers saw their stocks decline on Thursday, Tesla’s massive size meant that its gains lifted an index of auto manufacturers by 0.8% for the day.

‍

The stock movements were largely driven by Trump’s decision to impose a 25% tariff on fully assembled vehicles imported into the U.S. Tesla is expected to avoid the brunt of these levies since it produces all the cars it sells in the U.S. at its factories in California and Texas. Meanwhile, GM and Ford rely heavily on imported vehicles, making them more vulnerable to the new tariffs. However, the situation could become more complex if the administration proceeds with its plan to impose additional tariffs on imported auto parts, a move currently scheduled to take effect in May.

‍

For Tesla, Thursday’s stock move was relatively minor compared to its usual volatility. The company’s shares have faced significant fluctuations since the beginning of the year, having dropped 33% year-to-date as of Wednesday’s close. Tesla’s stock experienced a major selloff on March 10, wiping out roughly $130 billion in market value, only to regain about $95 billion in a rally on Monday. These dramatic swings alone exceeded the total combined market capitalization of GM and Ford, even though Tesla’s vehicle sales remain lower than its legacy competitors.

‍

Beyond Tesla, other beneficiaries of the tariff news included companies involved in the used-car market. Shares of CarMax Inc., as well as rental car firms Hertz Global Holdings Inc. and Avis Budget Group Inc., also saw gains. Analysts at Morgan Stanley, including Adam Jonas, suggested that these companies stand to benefit if new car prices rise sharply due to tariffs, making used cars a more attractive alternative for consumers.

‍

Despite concerns over the auto sector, broader U.S. markets showed little reaction to the tariff confirmation. The S&P 500 Index edged down just 0.1%, indicating that investors are not yet panicking about the potential ripple effects.

‍

However, the long-term consequences of the tariffs could extend well beyond automakers. Solita Marcelli, chief investment officer for the Americas at UBS Global Wealth Management, highlighted potential disruptions to supply chains, shifts in corporate investment strategies, rising consumer prices, and escalating global trade tensions as key areas of concern.

‍

“The more pressing issue is what these aggressive auto tariffs suggest about next week’s expected announcement on reciprocal and non-auto tariffs,” Marcelli noted in a client report. “We encourage investors to brace for a range of targeted tariffs and retaliatory measures that could heighten market volatility.”

‍

The uncertainty surrounding trade policy has already begun to influence corporate decision-making and investor sentiment. While Tesla appears to be insulated from direct tariff exposure, the broader implications of protectionist trade measures could impact raw material costs, supplier relationships, and the overall competitive landscape of the auto industry.

‍

The tariffs also introduce new challenges for legacy automakers like GM and Ford, which have global supply chains and manufacturing operations that rely on cross-border trade. For these companies, higher import costs could lead to price increases for consumers, potential shifts in production strategies, and disruptions in profitability.

‍

Meanwhile, some analysts caution that the tariff battle may not be limited to the auto sector. If trade tensions escalate further, additional industries could face similar restrictions, potentially affecting everything from consumer electronics to industrial equipment. The uncertainty surrounding future trade policy is likely to keep investors on edge in the coming weeks.

‍

For now, Tesla’s ability to sidestep the immediate impact of the tariffs has made it a relative winner in the market, while traditional automakers struggle to navigate an increasingly complex regulatory environment. However, with ongoing discussions about potential further trade restrictions, the landscape remains fluid, and the full extent of the tariffs' effects may take time to materialize.

‍

As the situation unfolds, investors will be closely watching for further developments in trade policy, potential retaliatory actions from other nations, and the broader economic implications of these measures. While Tesla’s stock movement has helped counterbalance some of the market’s concerns, the broader industry remains at risk of volatility and potential disruptions in the months ahead.

‍